Nomic@PCamp09

Round 4 Summary

admin — Tue, 23 Jun 2009 22:06:01 +0000

No moves were made.

Round 3 Summary

admin — Mon, 22 Jun 2009 23:00:19 +0000

hnauheimer proposed a rule: +2. It did not pass.
sdohrn proposed a rule: +2. It passed: +2.
adeep proposed a rule: +2. It passed +6.

Combine rules 7 and 8

adeep — Mon, 22 Jun 2009 11:08:13 +0000

Currently rules 7 and 8 say the following:

7. Whether the change has been accepted or not, its proposer will gain two points when it is evaluated.
8. In addition, if the change is accepted, the administrator will roll a six-sided dice. The administrator will then add the number of points that come up on the dice to the score of that rule’s proposer.

I propose to combine these two rules in the interest of simplification and as they could be considered two parts of the same rule.

7. The proposer of a rule will gain two points when it is evaluated. In addition, if the change is accepted, the administrator will roll a six-sided dice. The administrator will then add the number of points that come up on the dice to the score of that rule’s proposer.

Counter Proposal Rule 11: rewording

sdohrn — Mon, 22 Jun 2009 10:48:46 +0000

Every 5 rounds the players elect the game administrator by majority vote. Every player has as many votes as she has points on the scoreboard. If no player is nominated or nominates herself the current game admininstrator continues for another 5 rounds. Every player has the right to nominate another player, players cannot nominate themselves. Nomination can be done by a blog post. A nomination of another player will be rewarded by 2 points. Players cannot nominate themselves. Elected new game administrators can reject their election, in this case the player with the second most votes will be elected. If no other player has been suggested, the current game administrator continues for another 5 rounds .

—-

I am posting a reworded version of Holger suggestion as there were a couple of repetitions.

Let’s talk

mattcoop — Mon, 22 Jun 2009 00:50:49 +0000

In my initial admin blog post I said that every blog post should be considered a rule proposal. It doesn’t count as rule, but seems to have stuck as a guideline.

Let’s change that.

If you have a suggestion about how to improve the game, or a question, or anything at all to say, go ahead and make a blog post about. Think about it like starting a discussion thread in a forum.

And, even in rule proposals, feel free to include explantions, and to ask questions in the comments before you make your vote. Remember, whatever is not directly forbidden by the rules is permissible.

What do you all think?

Change of wording Rule 11

hnauheimer — Sun, 21 Jun 2009 20:52:04 +0000

Proposal for change of Rule 11

Every 5 rounds the players elect the game administrator by majority vote. Every player has as many votes as she has points on the scoreboard. If no player is nominated or nominates herself the current game admininstrator continues for another 5 rounds.
Every player has the right to nominate another player, players cannot nominate themselves. Nomination can be done by a blog post. A nomination of another player will be rewarded by 2 points. Players cannot nominate themselves. Elected new game administrators can reject their election, in this case the player with the second most votes will be elected. If no other player has been suggested, the current game administrator continues for another 5 rounds .

Remark: wording was not clear. I understand that it was meant that the rule applies if only a player nominates herself…

Round 2 Summary

admin — Sun, 21 Jun 2009 17:49:59 +0000

hnauheimer proposed a rule: +2. It passed: +5
- Amend Rule 6: “Several times a day One time per day, the game administrator will take all suggestions that are in the change queue and count up the AYEs and the NAYs. If there are more AYEs than NAYs, the rule (or rule-change) will be added to the rules of PCamp Nomic.”
lucy proposed a rule: +2. It did not pass.
sdohrn proposed a rule +2. It passed +6.
- New rule: “Every 5 rounds the players elect the game administrator by majority vote. Every player has as many votes as she has points on the scoreboard. If no player is nominated or nominates herself the current game admininstrator continues for another 5 rounds.”
adeep proposed a rule: +2. It did not pass.

New rule: Removal of proposals from the queue

adeep — Sun, 21 Jun 2009 12:19:03 +0000

A proposed rule / rule change will be removed from the queue after 5 days if it is not passed.

Game admin selection

sdohrn — Fri, 19 Jun 2009 20:17:43 +0000

PROPOSAL FOR A NEW RULE:

Every person who registers for an account on this blog is a player.

lucy — Fri, 19 Jun 2009 19:41:08 +0000

Proposed Change #2 Every person registered on this blog who proposes or votes is a player.